Would it have been better if Dingwall local history classic had never been published?
Register for free to read more of the latest local news. It's easy and will only take a moment.
THE fascinating process by which myth and legend become widely accepted 'fact' provoked lively comment at a trailblazing Dingwall book club throwing the spotlight on local history.
Dingwall Museum Book Group is considering Norman Macrae’s local classic, Romance of a Royal Burgh: Dingwall’s Story of a Thousand Years.
It's part of a wider effort by trustees at the town's museum to "bring more people into the museumand the museum out to more people".
- Dingwall's 1000 year classic under the spotlight
- Dingwall heritage day launches festival
- Historian delves into Dingwall census archives with fascinating results
The first meeting of the Dingwall Museum Book Group took place on the Tuesday before Christmas, hosted by the community library. The next meeting is on Tuesday, January 16 at 2pm.
"Would it have been better if this book had not been written? We could not be conclusive: writing it turned myths and legends into ‘facts’ everyone knew, but on the other hand someone had to write something like this at some stage, to give those who came after something to improve." - Jonathan McColl
Dingwall Museum Trustees' chairman Jonathan McColl said of the first meeting: "A dozen of us gathered, and the discussion was led and guided by Roland Spencer-Jones, a museum trustee.
"We were met to discuss the only book that specialises in telling Dingwall’s history: Norman Macrae’s Romance of a Royal Burgh; Dingwall’s Story of a Thousand Years. Norman Macrae (1866-1933) was a journalist here. He published his first book Highland Second-Sight in 1908, with stories from many sources. In his new book published 100 years ago in 1923, he retells the stories he learned from knowledgeable people and from books such as the Orkneyinga Saga and Dingwall shoemaker Robert Bain’s History of Ross (1899).
"Many years later Norman’s youngest son Alexander (Sandy) would become the last Provost of Dingwall’s Burgh Council before it was merged with the District council and he organised the first volunteers to set up the Dingwall Museum in the Town House.
"For the book group, we had read in advance the first three chapters, looking at the pre-history of the area, the Pictish period and the Norse. What came out for us from everyone’s contributions, especially Susan Kruse, another trustee and well-versed in these historical periods?
"The valley of the Peffery thousands of years ago was very different from nowadays and the Iron Age fort on Knockfarrel would have looked down on a marshy valley floor where the confluence of Conon outflow and tidal Cromarty Firth soaked it. Bain, followed by Macrae both stated that until the Pictish period it was marshy and uninhabitable up to Fodderty. There is (as yet) no evidence when it became possible to settle where Dingwall is now, and we all agreed this would be a great project to investigate through dated core samples.
"Over the centuries the valley was drained, whether naturally or through human agency, but remains could be seen on the 1789 Aitken map with fludders between the fields, and the 1790 Brown map drawn at high tide."
Much has been published about the early history in the hundred years since Macrae’s book came out. The Pictish symbol stone in St Clement's churchyard has Neolithic cup marks on it. There have been Bronze Age finds along the Heights, such as the axe-heads and neck ring found ‘in the Dingwall area’ now in the Aberdeen Museum, and not least the largest surviving gold hoard dating to the Late Bronze Age ever found in Scotland –now in Edinburgh, but brought back here for a temporary exhibition in 2000.
Mr McColl added: "The sagas must not be considered dependable histories, having been compiled from many orally-transmitted stories and written down long after they were first told, but we have the stories from Flateyjarbók (that Norman called the Orkades) and Orkneyinga Saga to give us a flavour. Even archaeological surveys are often not easy to interpret but we have the name ‘Dingwall’ (from Þing an assembly) to demonstrate this town was an admin centre.
"We talked about the Norse struggles with Picts and Scots, about Thorfin of Orkney and MacBeth of Moray. We realised the important strategic position this place held as a crossroads of the major land and sea routes, coast and river valleys and the ridges between, that gave reason for different rulers to possess it and build strongholds here.
"Susan posed the question: Would it have been better if this book had not been written? We could not be conclusive: writing it turned myths and legends into ‘facts’ everyone knew, but on the other hand someone had to write something like this at some stage, to give those who came after something to improve."
The next book group meeting was fixed for 2pm on Tuesday, January 16, again in the Dingwall Community Library. Those attending will discuss the next chapters on the period of the Earls of Ross and their Dingwall Castle.
