Row over NHS Highland compensation payments as MSP queries decisions made 'behind closed doors'; 'Healing' process payments following bullying probe back in the spotlight as MSP David Stewart issues Freedom of Information request
Register for free to read more of the latest local news. It's easy and will only take a moment.
MSP David Stewart has expressed his concern over legal advice apparently taken “behind closed doors” without a written record over how NHS Highland compensation payments were to be made.
Mr Stewart submitted a Freedom of Information request for the content of any legal advice after it emerged that compensation payments were run through the payroll system.
That has serious implications for victims getting payouts as some were immediately blocked from getting any welfare support as well as seeing the payments heavily taxed.
He also asked for the minutes of any board meetings, including sub-committees, where compensation payments were discussed but was told they also do not exist because it is an operational matter.
NHS Highland said: “The advice was not received in any formal documents or emails, but was discussed throughout the set up and launch of the Healing process by those working on the administration and delivery of the scheme, which included our legal and taxation advisors from Shepherd Wedderburn.
“The Healing Process compensation payments are an operational matter and have not been discussed in any such meetings.”
“I must say I was taken aback by the answers that were given as decisions were made behind closed doors and not taken for discussion at any committee or board meeting,” said Mr Stewart.
“This was not discussing people’s individual cases, but just the system of payment. I know from previous NHS Highland answers that any case recommended for compensation has to go to NHS Highland’s remuneration committee for governance reasons, although no personal details of that case is revealed.
“It’s just a mystery therefore that there was no oversight of the compensation system.”
The health board has written to HMRC in a bid for clarity but it was revealed last week that they have not yet had a response leaving victims awaiting compensation in limbo.
