Dingwall man ‘started a pattern of abusing partners since 2008’
A sheriff wondered what to do with the drunken sailor who appeared before him to admit his fifth domestic offence against the same woman.
Calum MacInnes (53) of Sir John Fowler Crescent, Dingwall, had been on trial last month at Inverness Sheriff Court denying assaulting the woman in a house in Evanton on February 4 this year by seizing her by the arm and neck to her injury and threatening or abusive behaviour by throwing household items at her.
The victim gave evidence which Sheriff David Harvie described as "compelling" on the first day of the trial, which was adjourned until October 9.
But in a dramatic twist, MacInnes's lawyer, Roger Webb told the Sheriff that his client was now prepared to plead guilty.
"Having done two things wrong, he has done the right thing now," Mr Webb said.
However Sheriff Harvie was not impressed. "Her evidence was compelling. She was forced to give evidence and was challenged that she was lying."
Mr Webb explained that MacInnes had "a serious drink problem" but was addressing it and had got a job back at sea.
Sheriff Harvie added: "He has a terrible record. Four previous convictions refer to the existing complainer and this is number five."
He then told MacInnes: "I find it extraordinary that you put the complainer through the ordeal of giving evidence."
The Sheriff noted that MacInnes had convictions involving another woman: "You seem to have started a pattern of abusing your partners since 2008.
"You have had custodial sentences before in respect of this complainer and have engaged in conduct which included weapons. It is clear that previous disposals have not worked."
READ MORE HERE:
• Tain man covered in blood spat at police officer in face, court told
• What Highland sheriff told Conon Bridge drink-drive care assistant
The Sheriff considered jailing MacInnes because of his record but acceded to Mr Webb's plea to call for a background report and an assessment for a domestic abuser's rehabilitation programme.
He deferred sentence until November 14, adding: "That report will have to be very positive. It is a two-year programme and I will be keeping an eye on you."
